Opinion

Good books 10, good movie versions nil

Has there ever been a movie which surpassed the book?
Has there ever been a movie which surpassed the book? Trevor Veale

OPINION: Why is the book always better than the movie?

I've been contemplating this important topic for a while now.

Of course it's almost as bad when you see a movie and it's not just worse, but completely different to the book it is "based" on.

After watching I Am Legend a few weeks ago, I downloaded the book on my iPhone and gave it a read.

Of course, there are certain similarities between the movie and book, but honestly, they are few and far between.

Many years ago I waited excitedly to see Looking for Alibrandi, the movie based on the book of the same name by Melina Marchetta.

The book was practically a rite of passage when I was growing up and remains one of my favourite novels.

The movie? Not so much.

The book ends on a positive note, but it's not conventional; the guy doesn't get the girl, or the girl doesn't get the guy in this particular instance.

But (spoiler alert) the movie caves in to the traditional happy ending, much to my disgust.

Stephen King is another favourite author of mine.

The translations of his novels to the screen have to be some of the most hit and miss efforts in movie history.

There are classics, such as The Shining, Misery, Stand By Me and Carrie, brought to life meticulously and with some effort made to be true to the books they were derived from.

But there have been some real duds, including Salem's Lot, Silver Bullet and Pet Sematary.

Has there ever been a movie which surpassed the book?

If there is any you can think of please tell me, because I'm drawing a blank.

Topics:  books, carlie walker, movies, opinion



WATCH: Video appears to show 'meteorite' that lit our skies

Strange light appears in Bundy's skies

Meteor and earthquake strike Queensland in one night

Some assumed it was “a flare” or a “power surge”

Hervey Bay blogger shares tips for growing online blog

Fashion blogger - Chelsea Neck.

A fashion for passion has built Hervey Bay quiet a following online.

Local Partners

'Baby' recreates famous Nirvana cover shot 25 years later

The baby from Nevermind album has recreated the iconic cover shot.

PREVIEW: Luke Cage origin story is a strong addition to MCU

Mike Colter in a scene from the TV series Marvel's Luke Cage.

MIKE Colter stars as latest Marvel superhero to get his own series.

Kate goes down fighting in heated Survivor elimination

Australian Survivor contestant Kate Campbell.

YOGA teacher's 'good guys' alliance fails to get off the ground.

Emily Blunt's (almost) singing career

Emily Blunt nearly became the British Britney Spears.

Angelina is blocking calls from Brad Pritt

Angelina Jolie has reportedly blocked Brad Pitt's number.

Apocalyptica 'seek and destroy' sceptics with 'master' set

Apocalyptica play Max Watts in Brisbane on their Shadowmaker Tour.

Review of final show of Apocalyptica's tour

$40million hotel, shops development project for Mackay

Mt Pleasant hotel and retirement accommodation, proposed at 194-202 Malcomson St.

$40m development to take Mackay to 'the next level'

Huge Gunalda service station set to open by December

NEW STATION: The Gunalda Service Centre, owned by United Petroleum, will include a 350-seat eating area and a truckers lounge.

The massive servo is the biggest United development in Queensland.

Property leader says Fraser Coast market is looking up

Positivity is the buzz word in the Fraser Coast housing market

Property 200m from ocean selling for just over $100K

BEACHCOMBER PARK: Work has started on a new $19.2 million development at Toogoom.

The estate's developer is offering huge discounts for early buyers.

UPDATE: Former rodeo champ's sale rained out, now back on

Larkhill local Ken Consiglio is having an auction of most of the things on his property.

'People kept showing up and we had to turn them away'

First stages of $25 million housing development underway

New development on Madsen Rd - The Springs.

The blocks of land are much bigger than usual