Opinion

OPINION: Religious observance or a symbol of oppression?

OPINION: Is the hijab a sign of religious observance or a symbol of female oppression?

This is the question I was left pondering when I read a story about a suburban council calling for non-Muslim women to wear hijabs for three hours as part of a social experiment aimed at "providing awareness, insight and education".

A week after the Reclaim Australia Rally, it still feels dangerous to touch this issue and try to have a mature discussion around it.

Far from being anti-Islam, I look around our community and see the good that people of the Muslim community are doing, particularly in the field of medicine.

And an invitation to try a hijab was extended by the Hervey Bay Muslim community earlier this year, which I believe had very good intentions.

Yes, extremism in any religion is concerning, but it should not define the Islamic community.

It's an interesting idea - that one about walking a mile in another's shoes, but I don't know if I can see the merit in this particular endeavour.

As a Christian, I would have no desire to wear an item of clothing that speaks to the observance of another religion - and my religious beliefs should be equally respected.

The other, darker, side of the equation is whether these garments symbolise oppression. With my predominantly Western viewpoint, this is a difficult issue to try to discuss.

To be asked to wear a garment that many see as a tool of female oppression, both here and overseas, even just for three hours, is something I would judge too offensive to consider even for a moment.

Topics:  carlie walker editors picks hijab islam opinion religion



Sunlander turns to rest at Hervey Bay Regional Gallery

Hervey Bay Regional Gallery - Three Foot Six The Sunlander. Gallery volunteer Barbara Watts in the main gallery with Glen O'Malley's photographs and Ian Smith's paintings.

The exhibition will be displayed until February 5.

Detour announced for Tinana interchange construction

A detour has been announced for the Bruce Hwy near Tinana.

The detour will last until the new interchange is completed.

BREAKING: M'boro man, 61, killed in crash at Dundathu

Emergency services are on scene at Dundathu.

A 61-year-old man has been killed in a single-vehicle crash.

Local Partners

Teen starts gofundme page to get to barrel racing worlds

RYLEY Burke may only be 15-years-old but that isn't stopping the teenager and his horses Rebel and Spin from working hard to live his dreams.


What's on: 11 gigs coming up at the Brolga

Xavier Rudd will be performing a benefit concert at the Brolga Theatre on January 21.

There's a gig for everyone with lots happening in coming months.

Why platinum selling Xavier Rudd won't charge to play M'boro

Australian singer songwriter Xavier Rudd at Bluesfest 2015

All funds raised at the show will go towards community support.

Donate unused items to help fight against breast cancer

The Mini-Field of Women is a tribute to all those affected by breast cancer in the community.

Hervey Bay man will host garage sale for Breast Cancer Association.

New doco argues ‘OJ Simpson is innocent, and I can prove it’

O.J. Simpson

NEW documentary series claims to have found “missing evidence".

REVIEW: Undressed is more than titilating entertainment

Nathan and Tahlia meet for the first time on the TV series Undressed.

'DIVERSE' dating show goes more than skin deep.

Will there be a Game of Thrones spin-off?

Emilia Clarke and Peter Dinklage in a scene from season six episode 10 of Game of Thrones.

HBO’S original programming president has teased fans.

Ed Sheeran's intimate gigs down under

Singer Ed Sheeran

CHART-topper playing invite-only shows in Australia next month.

Eddie McGuire's scandal-free focus and new-look Hot Seat

Eddie McGuire hosts the new Millionaire Hot Seat Super Game.

HOST wants out of the hot seat himself to focus on game show revamp.

Embattled Amber Sherlock back on TV after leaked video

Amber Sherlock seems to have brushed off the leaked video

Historical home leaves family's hands after 75 years

SALE CONFIRMED: The Gympie Regional   Realty team which sold the Ramsey property are (back) Mel Gastigar, Dorothy Palmer and Margaret Cochrane, with (front) home seller Terri-Jayne Ramsey.

Ramsey family played a huge role in Gympie's growth.

What a year 2016 proved to be

Entrance Island, Birtinya

Get the inside info from the agents themselves

REVEALED: What Coast wants in an international airport

Sunshine Coast business people share their views on what's needed

Time for a cool change

43 Eckersley Ave, Buderim.

Family home goes to the auction floor

Designer home set in lush tropical gardens

This home has it all and more

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!