News

Leniency requests to judges no longer permitted

GONE are the days when defence lawyers would request lenient sentences for their clients.

Submissions on sentencing are no longer accepted before court.

That means if you find yourself facing court, your lawyer can no longer suggest probation or a fine is appropriate for your offence.

Each court in Australia must interpret the case for itself, since a High Court judge refused to hear what penalty prosecutors were seeking in the case of two drug dealers earlier this month.

When the defendants argued it was procedurally unfair, the High Court said prosecutors were not surrogate judges and the recommendations were not required and should not be allowed.

Before the change, prosecutors would generally tell judges what sentences the guilty should face.

Magistrate Graeme Tatnell of Hervey Bay Magistrates Court said in court since the High Court case had been delivered, he had restricted the prosecution on making submissions on sentencing range.

On Monday, he made the decision to make the same restriction for defence.

Mr Tatnell told the court sentencing was for a judge, or magistrate, alone to decide.

"The moment you say a fine, or alternate sentence, is appropriate you're interfering with the course of sentencing," he said.

Hervey Bay defence solicitor John Milburn said in court, lawyers had a duty to their client and duty to the court and it would more difficult to advocate for what was best for his clients with the change.

Prosecutors and defence lawyers may still provide comparable cases.

Topics:  court, hervey bay, hervey bay magistrate, sentencing




Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Pregnant smokers a concern

FACT: Smoking during pregnancy carries a range of risks.

The World Health Organisation is promoting plain packaging.

VMR pleads with boaties

VMR MEMBERS: (from left) Gil Townson, Philip Wodhouse, Commodore John Smith and Juan Pereira.

Fraser Coast boaties are risking their lives by not notifying rescue

Tell your tastebuds to get ready for Relish

RELISH THE EXPERIENCE: Hundreds enjoy all the Relish Food and Wine Festival has to offer in Queens Park, Maryborough each year.

Relish Food and Wine Festival is on this weekend.

Latest deals and offers

Bennett, Langer, Thurston and others talk Cam Smith

Broncos and former QLD coach Wayne Bennett.

Broncos and former QLD coach plus past and present players talk about Cameron...

Barnaby Joyce talks Johnny Depp's dogs in Tweed

Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce talks about Johnny Depp's dogs Pistol and Boo...

Billy Slater talks Origin Team

Queensland Origin great Billy Slater.

Queensland Origin great Billy Slater talks about this years team and his return to...

Own Sunshine Coast property? You’re about to make money

UP AND UP: Property owners are likely to win from rent and price increases but tenants and first home buyers might not be so happy. Photo: Brett Wortman / Sunshine Coast Daily

Good new for property owners, not so good for buyers and tenants.

Sale nears on last large block of land in Coolum

The 43.37ha property on South Coolum Rd has sold.

South Coolum Rd property to be land banked