Drug trials on animals necessary, says expert


ONE of the scientists who is designing the testing regime for synthetic drugs says trialling novel drugs on humans without testing them on animals first is likely to be considered unethical in New Zealand.

Government will again debate whether novel psychoactives should be tested on rodents, rabbits and possibly dogs when they debate drug laws under urgency next week.

The law already requires legal highs manufacturers to use non-animal tests if they are available. But the Green Party wants it to go further and will seek an amendment to rule out all testing on animals.

Dr Malcolm Tingle, a toxicologist who is helping to design the testing regime, said international guidelines for medicines and cosmetics said that a product usually needed to pass five thresholds to be approved as "low-risk".

These thresholds were low addiction potential, low risk of harm to an unborn baby, low potential to cause cancer in later life, no cumulative effect after repeated use, and no likelihood of death after a single dose.

Should drug trials on animals be allowed?

This poll ended on 03 May 2015.

Current Results

Yes, it's either that or human lives are lost.


Yes, but only for drugs used by newborns.


No, unless there's a compelling reason.


No, risk the humans first, at least they can consent.


This is not a scientific poll. The results reflect only the opinions of those who chose to participate.

Dr Tingle, who was speaking in a personal capacity, said animal trials were necessary for some of these thresholds - such as the effect on unborn babies and system toxicity. Most of the other requirements could be trialled with non-animal alternatives.

Asked about whether psycho-actives could be tested first on humans without animal trials, he responded: "A Health and Disability Ethics Committee ... is likely to want to see some pre-clinical evaluation to assure them that volunteers will not suffer adverse effects.

"Without that assurance, the absence of animal testing shifts the ethical dilemma to human ethics committees and they are thus unlikely to approve any such study."

Another expert said it would be possible to test psychoactives without animals if they were made of a known chemical structure.

Professor Nick Holford, of the University of Auckland's pharmaceutical and clinical pharmacology department, said: "This would ... be on a case by case basis. If a new molecule from a well established and acceptably safe class was proposed for use in humans then it would be reasonable to go directly to humans for further testing of effectiveness and safety."

The Green Party bid to block animal testing appears likely to fail.

National would require support from New Zealand First or Brendan Horan to oppose the amendment because its coalition partners Act and Maori opposed animal testing.

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters said the party would discuss its position at caucus on Tuesday, but he wanted the testing regime to be as robust as a pharmaceutical testing system.

Mr Horan said the animal testing amendment was a distraction.

Topics:  animal testing animal welfare editors picks

Fact Check: Are One Nation's claims about Safe Schools accurate?

Steve Dickson with party founder Pauline Hanson.

The Conversation fact checks Steve Dickson's claims

Lions cakes the traditional treat

CHRISTMAS CAKE: Bonnie and George Fox selling the famous Lions Christmas cakes at Stockland.

It's the time of the year to start thinking about Christmas dinner.

Local Partners

Black Friday 2017 sales discount codes and secret deals

LOOKING for the best Black Friday sales and secret codes in Australia?

'Womanspreading': The bizarre new Instagram trend

Womanspreading is set to become the latest trend on Instagram. Picture: Instagram/anoukrielo

WOMANSPREADING is the latest trend taking Instagram by storm.

Caitlin Stasey slams ‘discriminatory’ fashion designers

Caitlin Stasey is not impressed by the way denim jeans don’t cater to the female form.

Aussie star Caitlin Stasey has hit out at the design industry.

Best pubs in Queensland: Never-say-die spirit going strong

Shaun McCubbin, manager of the Fitzroy Hotel which has been part of life in Rockhampton for more than a century.

Iconic pub 'part of the colour and character of a great community'

premium_icon Why bush turkeys are so horny

The Turkeys are causing a big problem on the Coast

Fed up man says he has a solution to keeping the amorous birds away

Electric car prices will soon be the same as petrol vehicles

Nissan has introduced the 2018 Nissan Leaf, the next evolution of its zero-emission electric vehicle.

Electric cars will reach price parity with petrol in 2025.

Warwick man's life forever changed after shocking crash

HAPPY BACK HOME: David Weir's life has improved since moving back to Warwick.

A shocking car crash left David Weir unable to walk or talk