Billy Slater does a shoulder charge on Sosaia Feki of the Sharks to stop him from scoring a try  during the NRL Preliminary Final match between the Melbourne Storm and the Cronulla Sharks.  (Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images)
Billy Slater does a shoulder charge on Sosaia Feki of the Sharks to stop him from scoring a try during the NRL Preliminary Final match between the Melbourne Storm and the Cronulla Sharks. (Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images) Scott Barbour

OPINION: This is not what shoulder charge ban is for

BILLY Slater should only be suspended for consistency's sake, but the episode that could rob the Melbourne Storm, Queensland and Australian champion fullback of a grand final swansong exposes what is wrong with the should charge ban.

Slater was penalised for a shoulder charge on a try-line bound Cronulla Sharks winger Sosaia Feki in Friday night's preliminary final at AAMI Park.

Slater stopped Feki from scoring in the game, which the Storm won 22-6, but was penalised and charged with a grade one offence.

It carries a one-game ban, which means unless Slater can beat the charge at the judiciary he will miss the grand final.

A rule is a rule, and on that basis alone Slater deserves to miss the decider. He made no attempt to tackle. I believe he braced for a collision it appears he's led with the shoulder.

I miss the shoulder charge, and I'd love to see it back in the game. My ideal scenario is if a player makes any contact to the head, they are sin-binned or sent off, and cop a five-game suspension. If it doesn't hit the head, it's fair game.

It's not perfect, but it puts the onus on the defenders and carries a significant punishment if that player gets it wrong, and avoids penalising players for what is a heavy, harmless hit.



High Tops school friends reunite after generations

premium_icon High Tops school friends reunite after generations

A reunion was held for the Pialba High Tops School

Why we can't name and shame child sex offenders

Why we can't name and shame child sex offenders

Do you think the laws should change?

Get a Fitbit Versa smartwatch with the Fraser Coast Chronicle

Get a Fitbit Versa smartwatch with the Fraser Coast Chronicle...

STAY up to date with the best local news and track your fitness.

Local Partners