Website pays lip service to allowing us to make decisions

EDITORIAL: It's one thing to say to your family: "We only have $5, should I buy bread or milk?"

But it's an entirely different for a government to effectively crowd-source its budget - particularly when the decisions people are being asked to make do not reflect a realistic take on the state's finances, nor the myriad options available.

The Newman Government's interactive website pays lip service to allowing Queenslanders to make the difficult decisions: "should we sell off assets, or cut the public service? Do we cut first-home owners a break, or give investors a hand?"

Unfortunately, logic dictates that the choices available online are a massive over-simplification of reality.

A multi-choice quiz with a realistic representative of the Budget choices would be unwieldy - fair enough -but the version that has been presented is so black-and-white that it has lost all meaning.

It may be a cynical view, but it seems to me that the budget tool presented to voters is not there to actually give them a choice or even just to gather public opinion.

It's there to show them how difficult it is to make choices - a move that seems aimed at garnering sympathy over what will undoubtedly be, for all Queenslanders, a painful budget no matter which way they vote.

That said - it's well worth having a look at, even if it's just so that you can be informed over what the ugly choices are likely to be.



GALLERY: Fleet blessing lights up to start whale season

premium_icon GALLERY: Fleet blessing lights up to start whale season

The Blessing of the Fleet attracted hundreds

M'boro memorial is world class: Brendan Nelson

premium_icon M'boro memorial is world class: Brendan Nelson

The emotional speech paid tribute to Butchulla men who served

A new way to remember WW1: Prime Minister

premium_icon A new way to remember WW1: Prime Minister

Mr Turnbull's eight-minute speech moved the crowd of hundreds

Local Partners